ChocolateHQ

Chocolate around the world

Where chocolate grows, where it is made, where it is eaten, and why the same word means a different object in every country — traditions, laws, milk processes and the arguments they produce.

Start here

  • Is American chocolate sweeter?

    The most-argued question in the subject, taken apart into the five separate questions it actually contains — with the legal arithmetic done rather than asserted.

  • Why chocolate differs by country

    Six causes of national character, in order of how much they explain. The one about milk is the one nobody knows.

  • Hot chocolate styles

    Four European drinking traditions side by side, and why the Spanish one is thick.

The growing map and the eating map barely overlap, and that is the whole story

Cacao grows within roughly twenty degrees of the equator and essentially nowhere else. Chocolate is eaten overwhelmingly in Europe and North America. Almost nothing else about this subject makes sense until that separation is in view.

IT IS A COLONIAL GEOGRAPHY rather than an agricultural accident. Cacao was domesticated in the upper Amazon and developed over millennia in Mesoamerica; the plantation economies that made it a global commodity were built by European powers, and the modern industry's structure — growers in one hemisphere, grinders and manufacturers in another, and most of the value added at the second end — is the direct descendant of that.

SO THIS SECTION HAS TWO HALVES that are usually kept apart and should not be. The producing countries have chocolate cultures of their own, some very old and some very new, and treating them only as origins on a wrapper is the specific error the catalogue's history section exists to correct.

Why the same brand tastes different abroad

Six causes, and the one people reach for first explains the least.

COMPOSITIONAL LAW sets a floor, and the floors differ. EU milk chocolate must carry not less than 25% total dry cocoa solids and 14% dry milk solids; the US figures are 10% chocolate liquor and 12% milk solids; the UK and Ireland hold a derogation for 20% cocoa solids domestically. Those are floors rather than descriptions, and the gap between the floors is much larger than the gap between the products.

WHAT IS DONE TO THE MILK is the largest single cause and is almost unknown outside the industry. Milk crumb — milk, sugar and cocoa dried together — gives the cooked, fudgy character of British chocolate. Controlled lipolysis, which releases butyric acid, gives the tang that divides opinion about American chocolate more sharply than anything else in this subject. Continental practice more often uses milk powder with less thermal history.

CONCHING TIME, HEAT TOLERANCE and BEAN SOURCING account for most of the rest — and familiarity accounts for more than anybody admits. The chocolate somebody grew up with becomes the reference every other chocolate is judged against, which is why these arguments are so heated and so symmetrical.

The European manufacturing traditions

Four countries whose reputations rest on genuinely different things — a texture ideal, a filled-chocolate format, a pâtisserie craft and a nut. Knowing which is which is more useful than any ranking.

Britain and the United States

The two markets that produce the loudest disagreement about chocolate, and the one where the causes are best documented — composition, milk treatment and what each side grew up with.

Mexico and Mesoamerica

Where cacao became chocolate, and where the drink is still made in forms Europe never adopted. These are living practices rather than historical ones and are written in the present tense.

  • Mexican drinking chocolate

    The drink as it is made now, foam and all — not as a precursor to something European.

    History and culture

  • Cacao in Mexican cuisine

    Cacao as an ingredient in cooking rather than as a confection.

    History and culture

  • Mole

    A family of sauces of which only some contain chocolate, and none is a chocolate sauce.

    History and culture

  • Cacao among the Maya

    What the archaeological and epigraphic record actually establishes about Maya cacao use.

    History and culture

  • Cacao among the Mexica

    Tribute, ritual and the accounts that have been embellished since.

    History and culture

  • Traditional cacao drinks

    Champurrado, tejate, pozol and the wider family, with the catalogue's evidence limits stated.

    Guides

Asia and the Pacific

The fastest-changing chocolate cultures in the world, and the ones least covered in English-language writing. Two of these countries grow cacao and eat it, which is rarer than it should be.

  • Japanese chocolate culture

    A market with its own aesthetics, its own formats and a seasonal calendar unlike anywhere else.

    History and culture

  • Valentine's chocolate in Japan

    Giri choco, honmei choco and White Day — the same festival, an entirely different practice.

    History and culture

  • Nama chocolate in Japan

    A ganache confection with its own legal definition in Japan, which almost no other country has for a confection.

    History and culture

  • Korean chocolate culture

    A newer market with its own gifting calendar and a strong café-driven character.

    History and culture

  • Cacao in the Philippines

    A producing country with a daily domestic drinking tradition — tablea, tsokolate and the batirol.

    History and culture

  • Champorado

    Chocolate rice porridge eaten with salted dried fish, and a relative of Mexican champurrado by way of the galleon trade.

    History and culture

  • Cacao in India

    A large and fast-growing market that also grows cacao, and a gifting culture in transition.

    History and culture

  • Chocolate at Diwali

    Boxed chocolate taking a share of festival gifting from mithai, and the practical reasons why.

    History and culture

  • Cacao in Indonesia

    One of the largest producers, with very little domestic chocolate culture — the growing-eating gap at its widest.

    History and culture

West Africa and the producing countries

Where most of the world's cacao grows and where very little of it is eaten. The records here are about the crop and the households behind it rather than about a confectionery tradition, because in most of these countries there is not one.

  • Cacao in Ghana

    A state-marketed crop, a quality reputation, and a farming population most chocolate writing never mentions.

    History and culture

  • Cacao in Côte d'Ivoire

    The largest producer on earth, and the structural pressures that come with it.

    History and culture

  • Cacao in Nigeria

    A major producer whose cacao history runs differently from its neighbours'.

    History and culture

  • Cacao in Ecuador

    Nacional, Arriba and a fine-flavour reputation that is genuinely about the bean.

    History and culture

  • Cacao in Venezuela

    Criollo, Chuao and the most mythologised origin in the subject.

    History and culture

  • Cacao in Peru

    Enormous genetic diversity and a recent transformation into a fine-flavour supplier.

    History and culture

  • The São Tomé cocoa scandal

    The moment a British chocolate industry had to confront where its beans came from — and what it did about it.

    History and culture

The Middle East and the newest tradition

The one place a genuinely new chocolate format has emerged in the last decade, built out of a pastry tradition much older than the chocolate in it.

How it travelled

The historical layer underneath every national tradition above. Chocolate's spread is a colonial history, and the records here treat it as one rather than as a sequence of European inventions.

Keep going

  • Cacao origins — Every producing country as a growing region rather than as a culture — climate, varieties and what the beans taste of.
  • History and culture — The full set of culture records, including the ones this hub had no room for.
  • Economy and sustainability — What the growing-eating gap means for the people at the growing end.
  • Chocolate types — The compositional standards this hub keeps referring to, with their sources attached.
  • What is happening now — The current state of the market these traditions all sit inside.